House Church Talk - speaking
Bruce Woodford
bwood4d at hotmail.com
Sun May 16 16:54:22 EDT 2004
Hi Tim,
You wrote:"Bruce said, "Nor can the covering that a woman is to have on her
head (when she prays or prophesies) and which a man is not to have on his
head (when he prays or prophesies) be THEIR HAIR! All you need to do to see
how ridiculous such a position is is to insert into the text the phrase
"hair on" in place of "covered" and "hair off" in place of "uncovered"!!!"
In response, Niv 1Cor. 11: 7 footnote (vs. 4) Every man that prays or
prophesies with long hair dishonors his head. (vs.5) And every woman who
prays or prophesies with no covering (of hair)on her head dishonors her
head-- She is just like one of the "Shorn Women" (vs.6) If a woman has no
covering. Let her be for now with short hair. But since it is a disgrace for
a woman to have her hair shorn or shaved. She should grow it again.(vs.7) A
man ought not to have long hair. Sorry, scripture trumps your opinion."
Dear brother, verse 6 of I Cor 11 makes the issue very clear! Here's the
KJV with "short hair" inserted for "not covered" and "long hair" for
"covered":
6 For if the woman have short hair, let her ALSO be shorn: but if it be a
shame for a woman to be shorn or shaven, let her have long hair.
The KJV "shorn" is identical to "short hair" and "shaven" is identical to
"no hair".
The word "also" Strong's #2532 translates our English words "and" and
"also". It is used thousands of times in the N.T. in lists and always
designates something IN ADDITION TO what precedes it. But short hair and
shorn hair are THE VERY SAME THING! But when we realize that I Cor 11 is
referring to a covering on the head, it truly is something ADDITIONAL TO the
hair!
You said you used the NIV, but your text sure doesn't look like the NIV to
me!! Nor did your replace "no covering" in verse 6 in your version with
"short hair" like you suggested!! If you had, the foolishness of it all
would have been readily apparent! "If a woman has short hair, let her be
for now with short hair!"
Here's the NIV with the same insertions:
6 If a woman has short hair, she should have her hair cut off; and if it is
a disgrace for a woman to have her hair cut or shaved off, she should have
long hair.
The NIV "hair cut off" is identical to "short hair". " Shaved off" is
identical to "no hair".
Your suggestion that the hair IS the covering with which the woman should be
covered when she prays or prophesies is contrary to scripture on a number of
grounds:
(1) As seen above it cannot account for something that is IN ADDITION TO the
hair as verse 6 requires.
(2) It does not account for the fact that the dishonor is ONLY ASSOCIATED
WITH TWO ACTIVITIES (praying and prophesying). If it really was the woman's
long hair, it would be associated with dishonor ALL THE TIME her hair was
cut short! If it really was the man's long hair, it would not only be
dishonouring to his head while praying and prophesying, but ALL THE TIME his
hair was long!
(3) It does not take into account the fact that TWO DIFFERENT EFFECTS ARE
NOTED relative to what we (men and women) do with our HEADS and our HAIR.
-What we do with our HEADS (covering or uncovering while praying or
prophesying) brings
HONOR OR DISHONOR . (I Cor.11:4-6)
-What we do with our HAIR (allowing it to grow long or cutting it)
brings GLORY OR SHAME.
(4) It does not take into account the fact that THREE DIFFERENT PARTIES are
affected by our choices regarding what they do with our heads and our hair:
-CHRIST is honored or dishonored by what AMAN does with his head
WHILE PRAYING OR
PROPHESYING. v.3,4 and 7a
-THE MAN is honored or dishonored by what A WOMAN does with her head
WHILE PRAYING
OR PROPHESYING.v.3,5,6 and 7b
-WE ALL are shamed or gloried ALL THE TIME by what WE do with our
hair. v.14
Dear brother, scripture trumps ALL our opinions!
Your brother in Christ,
Bruce
_________________________________________________________________
FREE pop-up blocking with the new MSN Toolbar get it now!
http://toolbar.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200415ave/direct/01/
House Church Talk is sponsored by the House Church Network.
House Church Talk has been renamed. These discussions, via the web, now occur at the Radically Christian Cafe.